Posts
This business trust owns hotels in Australia, China, Japan and Singapore.
Unlike rental income from industrial, commercial or residential properties, for examples, a hotel's income is less stable.
It has a strong element of seasonality.
As most of Ascendas Hospitality Trust's properties are in Australia, China and Japan, its income is also very much subjected to foreign exchange risks.
Hotel Sunroute Ariake in Tokyo is located in the heart of the Ariake area near the Tokyo Big Sight Convention Center.
To make it more attractive as an investment for income, at its IPO price of 88c a unit, yield was engineered to be higher through a 1 year waiver to income distributions by the sponsor.
The income forecast was also very optimistic.
To be fair, it was probably a difficult job to provide an accurate forecast and, in July 2012, I said:
"I feel that I need to be conversant in the economies of three countries and the health of their respective tourism sectors to analyse how well they could continue doing.
"I would also need to take into consideration that income would be collected in three foreign currencies and converted to S$ for distribution to unitholders.
"Foreign exchange rates would affect income in S$ terms.
"So, analysing this Trust and forecasting its future income is somewhat more challenging. It is less straightforward." (See related post #1)
I do understand that having properties in different countries reduces the risk of concentration.
However, whether it is worth having to deal with so much foreign exchange risk or not, I am not sure.
The Trust's unit price suffered a big decline when it did an equity fund raising through a placement to raise $50 million to partially fund the purchase of Osaka Namba Washington Hotel Plaza in Japan not too long ago.
The price?
68c a unit.
The number of units in issue increased by 7.1%.
Gearing is estimated to be about 38% while NAV per share is about 74c.
Its relatively high gearing level could be a source of concern although the Trust does not have any debt due till 2016.
I do, however, like that more than 83% of the Trust's borrowings are in the local currencies.
This provides a natural hedge against foreign exchange risk.
What about the DPU?
Well, although the DPU became more realistic with the expiry of the sponsor's waiver to income distribution, seasonality makes it inaccurate to annualise any one quarter's DPU.
So, instead, I simply added 4 consecutive quarters' income distributions which gives me a 12 months DPU of 5.5c.
This is probably more realistic than the forecast of 7.07c during the IPO.
At a price of 72c a unit, therefore, a realistic distribution yield is 7.64%.
Although the Trust has hotels in a few countries, most of its properties are in Australia.
So, how well the Australian economy and hospitality sector do will have a big impact on the performance of the Trust.
A stronger A$ will be good for the Trust.
Will this happen?
Well, if the much talked about recovery of the global economy takes place, then, yes.
For someone who is in search of more stability in passive income generation, hospitality business trusts, Ascendas Hospitality Trust included, might not be the best places to look.
However, if we feel that the Trust's current DPU is realistic (which is another way of saying "not inflated"), then, as an investment to diversify our sources of passive income, it might be worth a nibble.
Having declined to a price of 72c a unit, investors who got in at IPO would still be nursing a paper loss even after taking in the income distributions received so far.
They might want to ask if they were not already invested, would they initiate a long position at today's price?
Pullman Sydney Hyde Park - Australia
Related post:
1. Ascendas Hospitality Trust: Am I interested?
2. OUE Hospitality Trust: Considerations.
Bloggy Award