The email address in "Contact AK: Ads and more" above will vanish from November 2018.


Featured blog.

This guy has 800K in his CPF. (AK responds to HWZ Forum.)

A reader pointed me to a thread in HWZ Forum which discussed about my CPF savings being more than $800K. He wanted to clarify certain que...

Past blog posts now load week by week. The old style created a problem for some as the system would load 50 blog posts each time. Hope the new style is better. Search archives in box below.


"E-book" by AK

Second "e-book".

Another free "e-book".

4th free "e-book".

Pageviews since Dec'09

Recent Comments

ASSI's Guest bloggers

Get income from investments to meet interest payments?

Saturday, March 21, 2015

I remember when I paid off my housing loan many years ago, the interest rate that the loan attracted was 5.1%. That was pretty pricey. For a few years now, interest rates have been very low and, so, it has been pretty cheap for people to borrow money to help pay for their homes.

Personally, I am holding back from doing partial or full capital repayment on my current home loan because even with the sharp increase in the 3 months SIBOR in recent months, the effective interest rate on my home loan is still below 1.8%. The cost of having liquidity is not exhorbitant (yet).

Even if my investments are only able to generate a dividend yield of 4.0%, financially, I would still do OK. So, arbitrarily, an interest rate of 4% on my home loan could be the tipping point for me to want to pay it down at a faster clip.


I have been following your blog for about 4 months now and was rather impress with what you have.

I am in my early 40s and had just got a BTO which will be ready in 3 yrs time. When the house comes i will be down in loan by S$350k. Now i am with only S$50k in HDB Bank Loan with DBS Bank serving an interest of 1.6%. What i noticed is that out of my annual contribution to the Loan installment, about 60% will goes to the interest payment and only about 40% is paying up on my actual premium. That is alarming to me.

I had wanted to get a dividend income just like you, but if i were to have S$50k on hand, should i be paying up my loan or putting them into the dividend paying stock that gives about 6% return? Of course dividend stocks comes with value appreciation but no matter how we should not be thinking about stock price appreciation when talking about income generation.

One is for future payment and the other is for near term paying out of the housing loan. It seems that paying up on housing loan is the priority.

The next question for you is given two stock, A and B, A gives dividend yield of 6% and share price appreciation of about 4% and B gives Dividend yield of only 3% but has a share price appreciation of 10%, which would you consider for long term income?

Any advice from you will be most helpful.


Reply from AK:

Hi M,

A housing loan is amortising in nature. As we pay down the loan, the interest portion will shrink and the principal repayment portion will grow even as the monthly installment stays the same. If you would like to pay less interest, one way is to shorten the loan period. Then, you would be paying more of the principal amount monthly. However, your monthly installments would also be bigger, of course.

As for whether you should pay off the housing loan first or invest for higher returns, it depends on what is the interest payment on your housing loan and what you are able to get from your investments.

Imagine that you have a housing loan of $300,000 and that the interest rate is 2%. Let us assume that the loan is non-amortising for the sake of illustration. In a year, you would have to pay $6,000 in interest payment. If you were able to generate a 5% return through investments that year, you would make $15,000 which is more than enough to cover the interest payment.

Of course, there are good things to be said about paying down our housing loans ASAP no matter the interest rates or potential investment returns. Do what gives you peace of mind. That is priceless.

Now, as for stocks A and B, not an easy question because there could be so many different circumstances surrounding them. I would, however, first ask if the dividend is sustainable, if it is sustainable and if we are after passive income, I would go for stock A.

Price is, after all, often a function of Mr. Market's moods while there could be some certainty in dividend payments if they are sustainable. Like I said, bear in mind that this is actually a very simplified approach to a possibly very difficult question.

Best wishes,

Related posts:
1. A car loan is different from a home loan.
2. A new flat on the way and $200K in spare cash?
3. Newly married and planning for a child?
4. Interest rate on home loan jumped 15.84%!
5. POSB HDB Loan: Peace of mind (for 8 years).


blazingruby60 said...

hi AK
I have been following your blogs for a few years now and always appreciative of your sharing on many topics from cpf to stocks. I have a little issue I would like to bounce off some ideas from you or your readers of your blog. I am thinking of cashing out my freehold private apartment which is coming to 18 years (aging freehold property according to my property agent). .He advises us to sell as our private apt is surrounded by landed property which has little chance of enbloc and now with the enbloc fever raging there is more interest in freehold private prperty.
We are retiring in 2 years and would like more cash for retirement. It doesnt make sense to buy another resale HDB flat aka catching a falling knife. The newer hdb flat is asking for high price and resale flat is still thinking of a higher selling price. What would you advise me to do ? I am in a dilemma. Your advice is greatly appreciated thank you..

AK71 said...

Hi Ruby,

Typing the reply, it became quite lengthy.

So, I decided to blog about this instead.

Will publish the blog soon today. :)

AK71 said...

Here it is:
Should I sell my home and downsize or downgrade?

Monthly Popular Blog Posts


Bloggy Award