They chose financial independence over home ownership.

This is somewhat extreme but watch how this Canadian couple chose financial independence over home ownership.  They are in their 30s and,...

Past blog posts now load week by week. The old style created a problem for some as the system would load 50 blog posts each time. Hope the new style is better. Search archives in box below.


"E-book" by AK

Second "e-book".

Another free "e-book".

Pageviews since Dec'09


Recent Comments

ASSI's Guest bloggers

Should I sell my HDB flat to fund my condo purchase?

Monday, July 13, 2015

All of us aspire to a better life, to give our families a better life. This is only normal.

In Singapore, part of this aspiration to a better life for many is characterised by a desire to live in a condominium with full facilities and security.

For HDB upgraders, they might wonder if they should sell their HDB flats or hold on to them as income properties. The case to keep their HDB flats for rental income has been quite strong in recent years due to the buoyant rental market and the very low interest rate environment. It would be prudent to ask if such a scenario is going to last?

I replied to a reader who has the same question:

Hi H,

You have rightly identified the two main considerations which will help you in making a decision.

1. Interest rates have been very low for many years. They could stay low for a while more but they cannot stay so low forever. The very low interest rates of the last few years are abnormal. When interest rates normalise in future, the logical direction they will go is up.

2. How much we get in rental income, if any, like many things is a function of supply and demand. The oversupply situation in residential properties is not getting any better in Singapore and it will take years to correct (and we are assuming that they would). The slower growth in the foreign working population is not going to drive rental demand for residential properties like it did in recent times.

Would you be able to rent out your 4rm flat in Sengkang for $2.2K a month (if you could find a renter at all) in 2017? I do know it has been getting harder to find renters in recent months. I don't think anyone knows for sure what it is going to be like in 2017.

In life, I like to go for low hanging fruits. I try not to climb trees and if I do, I try not to climb too high up into the trees. I go for the benefits which I know I will be able to secure with greater certainty.

 Leverage is able to deliver benefits to investors if used correctly and if the conditions are favourable. The last few years saw households in Singapore leveraging more liberally because of the very low interest rates. Things still look OK now but a recent study showed that if interest rates were to normalise and rise by only 2%, 15% to 20% of households in Singapore could become overleveraged.

An overleveraged individual uses more than 60% of his income to service his debt burden. So, someone could be using just under 60% of his income now to service his debt burden but when interest rates rise, which they will sooner than later, all else remaining equal, he could end up using more than 60% of his income to service his debt burden.

Reading your email, I get the feeling that your preference is to sell your HDB flat when your condo is ready in 2017 so as to avoid paying a 7% ABSD (and also end up servicing a bigger home loan). Well, I would say to keep your ear to the ground and see how things develop in the next two years.

If the residential real estate market worsens and if interest rates go up much more, the case for keeping your HDB flat as an income property will weaken. We cannot project current day rates into 2017 and think that things will not change.

Leveraging to fund prudent investments is a good idea. Leveraging to fund consumption is generally a bad idea. Interest rates have been too low for too long and many people have grown a bit too adventurous.

Best wishes,

Related posts:
1. Buy that second property and pay the ABSD?
2. Should we buy a shoebox unit in NE Singapore?


apex property investment said...

Hi, I've been thinking of the same issue and I've about nett 90k to clear. To save for another 200k and clearing this HDB loan,I need about 4years. I countered, left right, left right, haiz, I decided to be safe. It's just 4 years more. At the most I lost 200k of gains which is potential gain - this point it's paper gain only. The downside of selling and changing to condo is real. Think again. I would play safe and wait a while.

Siew Mun said...

Sorry, I prefer the other way, monetize my condo and buy a hdb :-) I can reinvest the profits!

pf said...

It's very difficult to make any comments without any background to this request.

Actually if the family is middle age, fully paid up hdb, kids leaving home. But have 2 cars and gym membership or play tennis, it might make sense to move to a small condo to maintain same standards of living without separately paying for similar fees that they r paying when living in a hdb flat.

That is provided they are able to service a short tenor loan.

Or is moving to a condo for the purpose of putting children into a good school within 1km?

If there is no other purposes to justify the condo purchase, just don't think about it. Unless the family can afford 2 condos....How to rent out when the family is living in it? Rent out a room of the condo? Doesn't sound like the atas living one should get out of condo living. ....might as well stay in the hdb flat.

AK71 said...

Voices of reason. Thumbs up. ;)

Monthly Popular Posts

Bloggy Award