The reason for China Minzhong's trading halt in the last session has been published.
Indofood is paying 91.5c per share to take up a 14.95% stake in China Minzhong. Indofood is, of course, a leading food producer in Indonesia and some of us are familiar with their instant noodles in Singapore.
This surprise development is strongly positive for China Minzhong as they receive funds for further expansion of industrial farming facilities which will raise productivity and lower costs, making them more competitive. Industrial farming also means greater accountability and ease of audit which in turn should raise investor confidence.
There is also expected synergies between Indofood and China Minzhong, both established food companies in their respective countries of Indonesia and China which have huge populations which, of course, have to be fed.
However, before we send in the lion dancers and drums, Indofood is buying into China Minzhong through the purchase of new shares to be issued. So, unlike what happened in December last year when Olympus Capital Holdings sold its 10.3% stake for 80c a piece to various institutional funds and HNWIs, Indofood's buying into China Minzhong is dilutive for current shareholders.
The new shares which are being issued at a discount of about 10% from market price will water down the valuation of China Minzhong's shares by about 13%. On a per share basis, everything else remaining constant, we would see a lower EPS and a higher PER, for instance.
So, from a valuation perspective, if Mr. Market should go into protest mode on Monday and sell China Minzhong's shares at 90c a piece next week, it is actually not any cheaper than buying the shares at $1.03 this week.
If Mr. Market should go into a buying frenzy because of this development and push the share price to gap close at $1.20 per share, we should note that $1.20 is actually the old $1.38 from a valuation perspective. So, if we had a target price of $1.38 to sell, we should sell at the gap close of $1.20.
Of course, if we believe that this tie up will add fuel to the growth trajectory of China Minzhong, then, a higher PER becomes more acceptable. If Mr. Market believes this, it will be reflected in a much higher share price.
Unfortunately, there is no way to tell in which direction and by how much share price would move. We can only tell what this latest development means for the valuation of the stock.
See press release: here.
Related post:
China Minzhong: 2Q FY2013 stellar results.
25 comments:
1H13 operating cash flow came in at Rmb578.3m, much higher than the Rmb337m earnings due to prompt
collection of 2Q sales. As a result, net gearing fell to 5% from 15% at end-FY12.
We estimate Rmb550m of free cash
flow this year on the back of around Rmb1.1bn of operating cash flow and management’s capex guidance of Rmb550m. Should a modest 20% of earnings be paid out, CY13 yields would be a strong 6%.
Source:
http://www.remisiers.org/cms_images/research/Feb11-Feb15_2013/ChinaMinzhong15022013cimb.pdf
Management also hinted of declaring a maiden final
dividend (although the exact amount has not been decided) when full year results (to June’13) are
announced sometime in Aug ’13.
We are expecting 15% growth in profit to Rmb782mln for full year ending June’13, translating to an undemanding forward PE of 3.6x.
Source:
http://www.remisiers.org/cms_images/research/Feb11-Feb15_2013/dailyex15022013.pdf
wah indofood also jumps in liao... hahahaha...
i think soon all the seasoning would come from mz. hahahaha
As LT investor, will accumulate if see 0.90 again. It is better to go in at current adjusted price than the adjusted recent high. Selling is not an option as I am still accumulating.
Hi pero,
The new development seems promising. Only time will tell what will eventually happen, of course. :)
Hi seefei,
If Mr. Market should react to the dilution negatively and send the share price lower, my recent partial divestment in the company based on technicals could be viewed as fortuitous.
If valuations become more compelling, I too would buy more. :)
Hi AK71
I've looked at the past few annual reports for CM.
I am concerned that although top & bottom line grew at an impressive annual rate of 23% since 09, this wasnt translated to EPS growth itself, which grew only 2+% to 1.22RMB.
Based on FA, this doesnt make CM a compelling buy does it?
Am I missing something? Pls kindly enlighten me if so. Thanks!
Hi Unknown,
My research shows that earnings per share (EPS) for year ending June 2011 was RMB 1.04 and for year ending June 2012 was RMB 1.22. This is a 17.3% increase, year on year.
If I am not wrong, the EPS for FY2009 based on the enlarged share capital at IPO in 2010 works out to be about RMB 0.55.
Seems like Market is viewing this piece of news positively.
White candle with high vol. Accumulated a tiny bit more coz the trend looks upwards. :)
Hi Ray,
It is my first day back at work and I am totally swamped...
Wah! CMZ is up 12c! You are a nimble footed one! Congratulations!
HUAT ah! :D
UOB Kayhian has a new feature. It sends email alerts on the stocks on your watch list when it detects bullish or bearish signs. Some are false alarms but there are times like today when it is useful :)
Hi Ray,
Brokerages are getting more innovative in order to compete, I see. :)
I need to stay focused on one thing at a time. Otherwise, I become irritable. I better not subscribe to any alerts or else I become less alert at work... ;p
Hi AK
thanks for the response. referring to the annual report for 2010, pg 46, diluted EPS is stated as RMB 1.09 and 1.08 for 2010 and 2009 respectively. where can I find the figures you quoted? The figures for 2012 and 2011, I can see them. Just concerned that from 09 to 12, EPS growth has been minimal.
but anyway the counter stormed up today! ah...win some lose some =)
Hi Unknown,
I have the numbers scribbled in a notepad. I must have gotten it online from the IPO prospectus or some similar document. I hope I have not made a boo boo (which I sometimes do).
Yes, share price is up sharply today. Nice. :)
CMZ halted..... wonder why...
Hi Ray,
Nissin becomes a substantial shareholder like Indofood? Then, perhaps, they fight for control over China Minzhong just like what happened with F&N? ;p
haha...we're unlikely to be so lucky twice...
but I hope I eat my words. :)
Hi Jeremy,
I am sure many fellow shareholders would be more than happy to help feed your words to you. ;p
The Company has been informed by its substantial shareholder, Tetrad Ventures Pte Ltd that it has on 28 February 2013 fully divested its equity stake in the Company.
Probably a non-event and Jeremy wouldn't have to eat his words. ;p
Hi AK,
Any thoughts about the Senior Notes that CMZ is issuing?
Hi Ray,
Thanks for the heads up. :)
I took a look at the announcement but there is too little information to form anything more than a very general opinion.
Intention is to issue Senior Notes due 2018. How big is the issue? What is the coupon?
If the cost of debt is relatively low and if the money is going to be used in a way that will improve EPS, I am all for it. :)
We can only wait and see now.
"As no binding agreement in relation to the Proposed Notes Issue has been entered into
as at the date of this announcement, the Proposed Notes Issue may or may not materialise."
Link:
Proposed Issue: Senior Notes due 2018.
it seems Market doesn't like the news.... CMZ plunged quite a bit :) time to buy more? ;)
Hi Ray,
Indeed, Mr. Market doesn't seem to like the news but it could be just the weak longs using it as an excuse to sell.
Technically, the uptrend is intact and momentum seems good. Buy more at supports, you think? Your call, of course. ;)
Don't understand why CMZ needs money now, even after Indofood's injection.
Hi Ah John,
The management will have to explain to investors why the issuance is necessary. I will wait and see. :)
Post a Comment