PCRT: Full divestment.

In a recent blog post, I compared Croesus Retail Trust and Perennial China Retail Trust, explaining why although both are business trusts, the former is a better investment for income.

I avoided Perennial China Retail Trust at its IPO in 2011 believing that the distribution yield did not compensate investors sufficiently for the level of risk which they were being asked to take on. I only initiated a long position at a much lower price of 47.5c a unit much later in the middle of 2012.





I did that because I believed that the level of risk had reduced significantly and that the distribution yield of more than 8% or so was sufficient compensation while I waited for the Trust to deliver better results.

About a year ago, I mentioned that the earn out deeds which the Trust was distributing income from will be exhausted by end of the year 2014 and that the management must work harder to ensure its portfolio of assets pick up the slack. When I blogged about the Trust again in November last year, some encouraging progress was made.

In the latest announcements by the Trust, although I am pleased to see that progress continues to be made, I am very concerned that, by the management's own admission, the situation in Shenyang is still challenging. I recently shared this concern with some friends over a lunch gathering too. Shenyang Longemont offices, completed in 2012, is still less than half occupied by the end of December 2013.





So, where is the Trust's income coming from? Its 50% share of the properties in Shenyang contributed $2.25 million in Q4. Perennial Jihua Mall in Foshan contributed $1.28 million in Q4. Assuming that the Trust makes no progress and keeps the status quo, these properties should generate a gross revenue of some $21.56 million this year.

The 5th and last property in the Trust's IPO portfolio is Perennial Qingyang Mall in Chengdu. This is to begin operations in April 2014. This is a bigger mall than the one in Foshan and has secured 85% leasing commitment thus far. If we were to assume a similar level of revenue as what has been achieved by Perennial Jihua Mall in Foshan, this mall could contribute $5.12 million in yearly revenue or more.

So, realistically, the Trust's IPO portfolio of properties should be able to generate some $26.68 million in gross revenue on a full year basis. This is a conservative estimate, all else remaining equal. Not too shabby especially if we consider the fact that there is still quite a bit of vacant office and retail space to be filled.

However, there are costs to take into consideration. In the department of costs, there are recurring costs and one off costs. I will take in just the recurring costs in this analysis because they will impact results on a more enduring basis.





Trustee-Manager's fees, I estimate these at $6.8 million a year once Perennial Qingyang Mall in Chengdu is completed. Finance costs, I estimate these at $10.28 million a year. Assuming that there are no one-off costs in the full year which, of course, is most unlikely, these two major recurring costs would already amount to $17.08 million a year.

Remember that, in earlier blog posts, I mentioned that Perennial China Retail Trust could half income distributions to unit holders once the earned out deeds are exhausted by end of 2014? Now, using the numbers I just presented above, that statement could have been too optimistic.





In an unrealistically optimistic scenario, the Trust could be distributing $16.4 million of income to unit holders a year. Of course, this does not take into consideration possible further improvement in occupancy. However, it also does not consider costs apart from the Trustee-Manager's fees and finance costs. In such an instance, hypothetically, how much income is that going to translate to on a per unit basis?

Right now, the Trust has a DPU of about 3.8c a year. This translates to about $44 million a year for the Trust. So, proportionally, we could see DPU fall to 1.41c a year in 2015.

Now, when we are reminded of the fact that Perennial China Retail Trust said at its IPO that they would distribute at least 50% of distributable income to unit holders, DPU could then be as little as 0.71c in 2015.

Bear in mind that the Trust has two other malls under development, Perennial Dongzhan Shopping Mall in Chengdu (80% share) and an integrated development in Tongzhou (10% share). The former is to be completed in another year or so while the latter in another 2 or 3 years.

Progressive payments must be made and the Trust could either resort to more debt or tap the cashflow generated by its portfolio of completed assets. Which option would the Trust adopt? I don't know but I do know that DPU will take a big hit in 2015 no matter which option is adopted.

Now, what?





My assumption made last year that DPU, in the worst case scenario, will drop by half in 2015 and thereby delivering at least a 4% yield on my purchase price of 47.5c per unit has been very much undermined.

I do not know if the Trust will do better in the next couple of years but for me to stay invested would require a lot more than just faith in the management that they will deliver in future. I need to be adequately paid while I wait.

Last year, I partially divested my investment in the Trust at 61.5c a unit. Today, at XD, I divested my remaining investment at 50c a unit, booking a very small gain of 5.26% but I will receive the 1.9c per unit of income distribution as well.





This is probably a good time to remind myself of something Warren Buffett once said:

"Have the purchase price be so attractive that even a mediocre sale gives good results."

For anyone still vested in PCRT, I hope the Trust does deliver eventually and that its operating assets will do well enough to generate enough income for distributable income to be maintained. Otherwise, a big reduction in distributable income could also possibly lead to a big decline in stock price.

So, what do I think is a fair value for PCRT? I won't give a number but the day PCRT is able to offer me a reasonably attractive distribution yield using only 50% of its distributable income and at the same time maintain a relatively strong balance sheet, I could be interested again.

See: 4Q Financial Statements.
See: Presentation Slides.
See: Appendices.







After writing this blog post, I found that the latest issue of The EDGE has an article on Perennial China Retail Trust in which Pua Seck Guan revealed that he is looking into the possibility of liquidating some of the Trust's assets in order to continue funding payouts to investors to avoid disappointing them in 2015 and beyond. With this strategy, he hopes to continue giving a DPU of 3.86 cents per annum.

Although it is reassuring to a certain extent that there is a plan to maintain DPU, we have to remember that a plan like this, even if executed successfully, is essentially a return of capital. It seems to me like a desperate measure amidst very challenging conditions.

If we wish to invest in income generating properties and get a meaningful yield on our investment, I believe that there are better options available, options which would not have to resort to asset sale in order to fund future payouts.

Related posts:
1. Perennial China Retail Trust: 1H 2013 DPU 1.9c.
2. Perennial China Retail Trust: Progress in Q3.
3. Croesus Retail Trust and Perennial China Retail Trust.