Wife wants to sell HDB flat to buy condo (Part 2).

Thanks ak.

Sorry, didn't make myself clear.

She's intending to sell current HDB to buy condo for own staying.

So rental probably not a big concern.

I'm just trying to consider when is a good time to do such "upgrading".

Sell HDB now will not lose but won't earn much.

But selling HDB during recession would save more if condo prices fall more so perhaps make sense to wait for recession.

Do you (just your own thoughts) think govt may lift ABSD if recession hits? 

Hi R,

The health of the rental market will determine the market prices of real estate to a large extent. So, if the condo rental market continues to soften, condo prices will continue to come under pressure. For own stay or rental, this is something to bear in mind.

Our home is a consumption item. It would not be wise to overstretch our finances to stay in a more expensive home and I know a few people who overstretched.

If we are able to afford a condo quite safely (i.e. it does not impact our balance sheet badly and it is not reducing cash flow to a trickle), then, good.

If I had to sink further into debt and if my monthly cash flow is reduced drastically because of this purchase, I would worry.

Of course, always think about the opportunity cost. For example, if I had to dispose of income producing assets in order purchase this condominium, I would think twice.

Staying in a condominium does not give any financial security.

Personally, I do not think that the ABSD will be lifted soon. When interest rates start rising in a sustained manner, maybe. Just a guess.

However, you might want to ignore all that I have said as keeping your wife happy might be worth the price to you.

This is where I should stop talking to myself.

Best wishes,
AK

Related post:
Wife wants to sell HDB flat to buy condo.

Wife wants to sell HDB flat to buy a condo.

Hi ak,

My wife had been hankering me about buying a condo coz her sisters all have multiple condos. All renting to service loans. I just feel we are late to the properties game and don't want to get caught in a bloodbath.

In order not to pay ABSD, she thinks we should sell our current flat. But the market is so bad now I don't know whether we could sell at all.

Her argument is if we wait for market to worsen,  though we may get the condo cheaper but our flat price would also drop. So there is no best time.

What would you do if you are in similar position?

Thanks.
R

Hi R,

1. Fact. Rental market is getting softer and softer. Even if prices of condos come down a bit more you could be setting yourself up for disappointment as vacancy rate continues to go up and rental market stays soft.

2. If I could, I would have bought a BTO HDB flat. If I had a HDB flat, I wouldn't sell it, especially not because I want to avoid paying ABSD on a second property if I am going to buy one.

3. When a crash happens, condo prices will drop more than HDB flat prices in absolute dollar terms. 

OK, now comes the difficult part.

If I were in your shoes, my stress level is probably through the roof because I am not the type to throw pragmatism out the window to please my other half.

Good luck. :)

Best wishes,
AK

See Part 2: here.

Related posts:
1. Disastrous property investments.
2. If we are not rich....