9M 2015 passive income from non-REITs.

Some wonder if Mr. Market could go into a depression? I don't know but I do know that many stocks became much more attractively priced in the last three months.

Consistent with my strategy to diversify my portfolio to reduce reliance on S-REITs for income, I added to my long positions in the following as their stock prices declined more significantly recently:

1. Accordia Golf Trust

2. Ascendas Hospitality Trust

3. ST Engineering

4. Starhub

5. SembCorp Industries

In the last three months, I also initiated long positions in the following as investments for income:

5. VICOM
"A 15x PE ratio would give us a fair value of $5.36 or so per share."

6. Religare Health Trust
"Trust has demonstrated its ability to improve its revenue organically quite strongly which makes up for the expiration of the sponsor's waiver to their share of the distributable income."

7. King Wan
"King Wan is in a net cash position and it also has an order book that would provide earnings visibility until 2018."

Finally, I accumulated the following stocks which have a bit of an income investing angle but the main reason is because I think they are worth much more and at lower prices, they became even more attractive:

8. Wilmar

9. OUE Limited

If you should be interested, you could search ASSI for more of my blog posts on these stocks and why I decided to add them to my portfolio when I did.

Of course, stocks could stay undervalued for a long time but regularly receiving some dividend in the meantime makes the waiting more palatable. I like to be paid while I wait.

If you suspect that I have dipped into my war chest in the last three months, you are right. 

Could we see another big decline in the stock market? We could and we should be ready. So, being cautious, I have not exhausted my war chest.

I have a couple of fixed deposits maturing next month in October and I will probably be keeping the money close at hand instead of putting it in another fixed deposit or two.

In Q3 2015, the following non-REITs paid dividends:

1. SATS

2. Old Chang Kee

3. APTT

4. SingTel

5. SCI

6. SMM

7. Wilmar

8. NeraTel

9. ST Engineering

10. QAF Ltd.

11. Starhub

12. HongLeong Finance

13. Croesus Retail Trust

For the first 9 months of 2015, total passive income received from non-REITs: S$ 57,747.59. 

This works out to be S$ 6,416.40 per month.

Have a shopping list and be ready to pounce if Mr. Market becomes depressed.

Related post:

6M 2015 passive income from non-REITs.

An incomplete analysis of Wing Tai Holdings Limited.

Wing Tai Asia.

Someone asked me that since I bought into OUE Limited at a 50% discount to NAV, why not Wing Tai? Wing Tai's NAV/share is $3.78 and it last traded at only $1.74. That is a massive 54% discount to NAV.

Well, both OUE Limited and Wing Tai might be in the real estate business but they are not exactly the same. Wing Tai makes most of its money from property development, more than 80%, in fact. On the other hand, OUE Limited keeps its exposure to property development to a smaller 20% or less.

Of course, we know that in the current day environment with all the cooling measures in place and also an impending increase in interest rates, property development business is really not as promising as it was a few years ago.

We could say that Wing Tai also develops properties in Malaysia and China but are the residential real estate markets there insulated from rising interest rates? I would think not.

In an environment that makes building and selling residential real estate difficult, it is the property companies which have strong recurring income streams that will weather the downturn better. In this area, Wing Tai is rather weak as its investment properties are a small fraction in value compared to its development properties.

Undeniably, for Wing Tai to do well, its development properties will have to sell well but it seems unlikely that this is going to be the case.

Revenue has dropped significantly in the last 12 months and the decline could continue for some time to come. Although Wing Tai's boss said that they are not dropping prices to move stock, I would not be surprised if he should eat his words in the next 12 to 24 months.

Unless some of the earlier cooling measures should be removed by the Singapore government, things are unlikely to look up for the property sector. Unless interest rates stay low in future, investors are more likely to avoid investing in properties.

Wing Tai will have to pay extension charges for development properties which have not been sold two years after receiving their TOPs. It will be a percentage of the respective sites' purchase prices. 8% in the first year, 16% in the second year and 24% in the third and subsequent years.

To avoid paying these charges, Wing Tai could do a SC Global and privatise but with only slightly more than 50% of the issued shares in their control, it would cost the Cheng family quite a fortune to do so and Wing Tai's boss has already said that there is no plan to privatise.

I am not an expert analyst on the property sector and I am not sure how well Wing Tai's properties will sell in future but I am willing to bet that conditions will continue to be difficult. Revenue could continue to decline and if Wing Tai should drop prices on its development properties, revenue could receive a boost but earnings might be flat.

The question now is really what is Wing Tai worth on a per share basis?

Well, I am more sanguine about its investment properties than its development properties. Those are worth about 72c or 73c a share. These properties are recurring income generators. Income could be increased by improving occupancy levels or increasing asking rents or rates where possible.

As for its development properties, the only way for them to make money for Wing Tai is if they were sold. Otherwise, even if we were to assume further write downs in value, they are just dead weight if they remain unsold. With the extension charges payable 2 years upon receiving their TOPs, they will become liabilities until they are sold. Therefore, to be very conservative, taking into consideration possible bigger write downs in future, to me, they could be worth $1.50 a share.

Wing Tai has cash on hand but not enough to pay off all its borrowings. They are short of some 58c per share. However, unless things get seriously bad, Wing Tai is in no danger of going belly up. It could always sell a fraction of its development properties cheaper to raise cash. At the moment, with the cash that it has, Wing Tai is at least able to reduce borrowings further in case interest rates should go up in order to avoid higher finance cost.

So, based on this incomplete analysis of Wing Tai Holdings Limited, to me, a fairly good entry price would be $0.72 + $1.50 - $0.58 = $1.64, give or take a few bids.

Technically, $1.64 looks like it could be tested as a support while in the short term, we could see a rebound in share price as the MACD formed a higher low.

See: Full Year 2014 Financial Statements.

Related post:
OUE Limited: A nibble.

Formerly Wing Tai's headquarters.

OUE Limited: A nibble.

On 25 September, I wondered in a blog post if I might be given a chance to pay 50c for what was worth a dollar. I am referring to OUE Limited's stock, of course.

Twin Peaks.

Although already trading at a hefty discount to NAV back then, I was concerned about how its luxury condominium project, Twin Peaks, could be a drag on performance. Also, looking at the charts then, selling pressure showed no sign of weakening. So, I decided to wait.

Today, I became a shareholder of OUE Limited as my overnight buy order at $2.01 a share was filled.

As the NAV/share is $4.04, I have paid 50c for what is worth a dollar. My wish came true.

It is a very small long position as sentiments are still very bearish and if the $2.00 psychological support should give way, we could see lower prices.

Could we see $1.96 or even $1.92? It could happen but it might not. If it should happen, I suspect that it could be a slow slide downwards. So, I am not going to be too hasty or "show hand" as some readers would say.

If the stock should be well supported and if the support at $2.00 should hold, then, I could add more to my long position if a reversal should take place.

Related post:
OUE Limited: An asset play that could be cheaper?

OUE Limited: An asset play that could be cheaper?

I have been eyeing OUE Limited since May this year but I haven't bought its stock. What attracted me is the big discount to NAV (NAV/share is $4.04) although its earnings per share is nothing to shout about. In fact, I estimated the PE ratio to be about 30x when I was crunching some numbers.

So, if the NAV is realistic, to me, OUE Limited is an asset play and with asset plays, the question is really whether the value will be unlocked at some point in the future. There is a likelihood that this would happen as OUE Limited hold stakes in OUE H-Trust (43%) and OUE C-REIT (42.5%).



Regular readers know I scribble my research on scrap paper.

A bug bear for OUE Limited now is Twin Peaks. This 99 year leasehold project (from 2010) is a luxury condominium they are developing near Orchard Boulevard in Singapore. They are having a hard time moving unsold units and of the 462 units available, only 20% or so have managed to find buyers.

The condominium is near completion and I think OUE Limited will then have 2 more years to sell all units or face yearly penalties. Already, they have written down the value of Twin Peaks by $105 million in the face of a challenging environment this year.

At an average selling price of about $3,000 psf and a GFA of about 436,000 sq ft (including balconies), I estimate the value of Twin Peaks to be about $1.3 billion, if fully sold. However, I doubt that it is going to happen without a deep price cut if the big discount given by Bukit Sembawang to sell its completed condominium in Cairnhill recently was anything to go by.

To be fair, however, Twin Peaks is just one part of OUE Limited's portfolio. The company owns many commercial properties and if their values are realistic, OUE Limited could turn out to be a very rewarding asset play for investors in time to come when their values are unlocked. When will it happen? Your guess is as good as mine.

Click to enlarge.

Technically, OUE Limited's share price is in a downtrend and it is one that shows no sign of weakening. So, although already trading at a big discount to NAV, I wonder if its share price could sink lower for me to get a dollar for fifty cents.

I wasn't going to blog about OUE Limited until I have initiated a long position, if I do at all. However, reading a blog by Brian Halim gave me a little push to share my thoughts.

Read Brian's blog on OUE Limited: here.

Related posts:
1. OUE H-Trust.
2. OUE C-REIT.